Playing With Matches

What started as a means of chronicling the online dating experiences of two picky yet adventurous almost thirty somethings has turned into a chronicle of all that is, was and has made up their collective dating histories. Our two original daters are now joined by several other fun, breezy, sassy gals, and Playing With Matches is now a missive on dating misadventures, a cacophony of ups and downs, turmoil and bliss. With a bit of snark mixed in here and there.

Friday, October 06, 2006

Don’t put that in your mouth, you don’t know where it’s been.

A fine kindergarten lesson, no? Or, in the world of dating, definitely a good rule of thumb.

Yes, friends, today we are going to collectively discuss a topic that, until now, might have been thought taboo on this blog. But, since we all talk about it anyway, we thought we’d share our great insights and horror stories, opinions and gripes.

I’m talking about what Katie Couric so aptly termed “the new third base.”

So. Much. To. Say.

Unfortunately, not much time to say it. So, this entry may come in daily, weekly, or monthly installments. Here's the first.

Let’s start with the age old debate of “this is way more intimate than sex, why can’t we just have sex?” Men tend to say it and women, in our experience, are often great defenders of the opposite opinion. Many believe that, while tangibly and physically more intimate, the new third base is not, in the least, more emotionally intimate. In our experience, men have a difficult time accepting this argument. Some of us have had many a conversation (during inopportune times, mind you) regarding this topic. Women cling to the emotional components of these encounters. This act contributes to far less “baggage” than the other. Trust us.

Why the difference in opinion? Some of us hold out on the actual s-e-x and partake in everything but (EB) because, for us, it means less. Some of us have been “complimented” on our willpower (*ahem* stubbornness). There are many reasons why it’s different, the least of which is not that IT JUST IS.

This is not to say that the act isn’t equally, or almost as equally, emotionally tying as sex, just not more. While we may think it carries less “baggage” than sex, we also, perhaps paradoxically, believe it can tie you emotionally to a person who you might not have been all that into in the first place. Therefore, one could argue that this act should only be undertaken in a relationship where you are monogamous or, at least, comfortable and where you know someone’s disease potential (scary but true, says the sex ed instructor), but where you are still scared, nevertheless.

This is not an endorsement of the idea that sometimes ‘the new third base’ is less scary than sex with a new partner, that it should be undertaken casually, or in the back of school buses.


Some of us, however, are of the opposite opinion. Rounding third base does not bond us to the lucky man in any way, shape or form and does not cause emotional attachment. However, once we have become emotionally attached to our partner, we become far more willing to initiate this.

Then there are others of us who find oral sex to be more intimate...especially if performed on them. Because you feel more exposed and all the attention is being focused on you and your happiness, on what you want, it allows for greater intimacy. This, of course, is all relative to the act of actual sex, which is—at least sometimes—a mutually beneficial experience.

Of course, there are some out there who don’t differentiate between the two. If you’re willing to do one, you’re willing to do another.

There you go. But we'll leave you with this (unrelated) thought: men, do not casually mention in conversation the fact that you saw a great t-shirt the other day that said “Spitters are Quitters.” This sighting is not at all appropriate to tell the girl you are dating, especially if you are just getting to know each other. Girls remember the things you tell them. And that is something that will definitely stick (haha). We have all heard of this shirt, and it makes us want to gag.

10 Comments:

Blogger romance junkie said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

12:55 PM  
Blogger Frankly, Scarlett said...

well i think that the risks are actually very understated. Girls (especially those who still mark their sexual expoits in baseball terms)are more willing to 'gag' because it does not carry a pregancy risk with it and therefore, safe. They don't really think about the fact that STDs (including HIV) can be transmitted in this manner as well.

Personally, I'm typically do not find myself as emotionally affected by 'gagging' as opposed to sex, where it is indeed difficult to emotionally extract yourself from the sitation.

We're all adults...can't we just lump them all into sexual acts which if performed under normal circumstances are all completely healthy and acceptable part of ones sexual repitoire?

1:26 PM  
Blogger NotCarrie said...

I do think it needs to be stressed to the 'kids' that there are the same risks for both acts. Besides pregnancy, a person still has to be really careful.


And I hate guys who expect it. Asses.

3:38 PM  
Blogger allan said...

RJ: Off-topic (and because I am not sure I want to wade into this conversation ;), but in answer to your question on my blog. An oaky Chardonnay or Sauvignon Blanc goes well with popcorn.

If you are specifically trying to match the wine to the movie, it depends on the type of horror movie. A slasher movie (ala Texas Chainsaw Massacre) I would recommend a Shiraz blend from Australia...something with deep reds). If you are talking more about a suspense movie (ala anything Hitchcock) then a Bordeaux or a Meritage, something complex with many layers....

4:49 PM  
Blogger romance junkie said...

thanks allan:D

5:48 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm more willing, in the early stages of a relationship, to go down on a guy then let him go down on me. I prefer to hold off on that for some reason.

11:19 AM  
Blogger romance junkie said...

yeah and going with the title you don't know where it's been...yeah you can use a condom with oral...but really...who honestly does that...but it's really easy to put one on and hit the sheets

7:47 PM  
Blogger dr. strangelove said...

Good emphasis on safety, RJ. What I'm getting from this in the midst of my affair is that it's safest when it's done to me. I'm okay with that. ;-)

10:02 PM  
Blogger Shorty said...

What an interesting topic! In my own experience, when a member and an orifice meet, the lines of intimacy are truly blurred :) More often than not, I feel I am less likely to be evaluated when engaging in "actual sex" than oral sex. When giving oral sex, the receiver is solely focused on the giver...anything is up for criticism. When receiving oral sex, the pressure to reach a goal often overwhelms the pleasure of the act, if the intimacy is not present. Both parties take a hit during "actual sex," so I think it relieves a bit of the pressure. That being said, I am pro-all-forms-of-sex as long as my co-participant is appreciative and healthy ;)

10:59 PM  
Blogger romance junkie said...

ha :D love it!

10:40 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home